News
Cardinal Zen asks Leo XIV to close the Synod on Synodality
Cardinal Joseph Zen asks Pope Leo XIV to close the Synod on Synodality and to remove Cardinal Fernández; we measure his appeal against the perennial teaching on the hierarchical constitution of the Church.

Cardinal Joseph Zen, bishop emeritus of Hong Kong, has published on his personal blog a text addressed to Pope Leo XIV. He asks him to put an end to the Synod on Synodality and to remove several of those who conduct it. Cardinals Mario Grech, secretary general of the Synod of Bishops, and Jean-Claude Hollerich, general rapporteur, should in his view be sent on a “long vacation”; Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández should be removed from the prefecture of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith.
The cardinal denounces “hidden agendas” pursued through the synodal process: altering the hierarchical constitution of the Church, ordaining women beginning with the diaconate, making celibacy optional for the Latin clergy, and “updating” sexual morality “under the L.G.B.T.Q. banner.” These aims, he asserts, have failed, the members of the assembly having rejected them despite “incessant manipulation” and a “strict control” of the process. He grounds his argument in the example of Saint Charles Borromeo and the Council of Trent, and recalls that “a synod is, by definition, a matter for bishops.”
The hierarchical constitution of the Church is of divine right
The Church did not receive from her Founder the freedom to remake her own structure. The Council of Trent teaches, on the sacrament of Order, that there exists in the Church a hierarchy instituted by God Himself: “If any one saith, that, in the Catholic Church there is not a hierarchy by divine ordination instituted, consisting of bishops, priests, and ministers: let him be anathema” (session XXIII, canon 6). The same council declares bishops superior to priests and successors of the Apostles (canon 7). The office of the bishop is therefore not an honorary title to be diluted in a “walking together”: it is the government that Christ entrusted to the successors of the Apostles.
What some claim to “update” likewise escapes the power of an assembly. The priesthood, and with it the degrees of Order, is reserved to men: the Apostle forbids a woman to teach and to exercise authority in the assembly — “But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to use authority over the man: but to be in silence” (First Epistle to Timothy, II, 12). The celibacy of clerics engaged in sacred orders belongs to a discipline that Trent defends under pain of anathema against those who reject it (session XXIV, canon 9). And the law of the sixth commandment is not a usage to be revised with the times, but a precept of the law of God.
The measure
The ends the cardinal attributes to the synodal process aim precisely at what the faith places above every vote: the constitution of the Church, the subject of the priesthood, the discipline of celibacy, the moral law. On these points an assembly does not deliberate, it guards. Where a synod would change what Christ has fixed, it would step outside its charge, which is to transmit and not to innovate. That these aims were, by the cardinal’s own admission, rejected by the members changes nothing of the principle: no majority would have had the power to adopt them.
We report here the word of a cardinal, published under his name; it binds him alone, and not the Apostolic See. What does bind him, on the other hand, is the measure to which he himself appeals: Trent and Saint Charles Borromeo. By that standard, his warning stands.
What the faithful should hold
The Church cannot give herself a constitution other than the one received from Christ. The faithful formed in the tradition have nothing to fear from a debate whose conclusions, if they claimed to touch these truths, would by that very fact be null. He holds what the Church has always held, and he holds it the more firmly for being told it is negotiable.
Sources. Council of Trent, session XXIII (1563), on the sacrament of Order, canons 6 and 7; session XXIV (1563), canon 9, on clerics engaged in sacred orders; Catechism of the Council of Trent (1566), on the sacrament of Order and the sixth commandment; Saint Paul, First Epistle to Timothy, II, 12.