News
In the Amazon, Leo XIV demands justice for the murdered defenders
In the Peruvian Amazon, Pope Leo XIV demanded justice for the forest defenders who were killed: tradition grants it to him in the name of the fifth commandment.

Returning on the next-to-last day of a twelve-day journey through South America, Pope Leo XIV entered the Peruvian Amazon. At Pucallpa, along the Ucayali, before indigenous representatives and missionaries, he demanded justice for the defenders of the forest killed for protecting it, recalling the fifty-seven murders of environmental defenders that organisations estimate took place between 2010 and 2024. He supported the efforts of indigenous peoples to keep their lands from being ravaged by illegal logging and clandestine gold mining, which uses mercury to extract the ore, and he denounced an "insatiable thirst for domination." He also spoke of the rise of sexual violence against Awajún and Wampís schoolgirls of the region. "The blood of these brothers cries out to God and demands justice," he said; "the cry of the earth and the cry of the poor are inseparable."
Peruvian justice, in 2025, upheld a twenty-eight-year sentence against four timber merchants for the murder of four indigenous men who had opposed the logging; in August, a court sentenced four people to terms of up to thirty-five years for the 2023 assassination of the Kichwa leader Quinto Inuma Alvarado.
What the Church has always held
The fifth commandment, "Thou shalt not kill," is no respecter of persons. The Catechism of the Council of Trent states it without nuance: the law "forbids murder to all the world. It excepts no one; neither rich, nor poor, nor powerful." And: "There is no one, whatever be the lowliness of his condition, who is not protected by it." Voluntary homicide is among those crimes whose blood rises to heaven: when Cain had killed his brother, God said to him, "the voice of thy brother's blood crieth to me from the earth" (Genesis 4:10). The same Catechism teaches that the murderer lays a criminal hand upon the image of God in man, and it recognises in the magistrate, "the legitimate avenger of crime," the duty to punish the guilty in order to protect the innocent.
The measure
To demand that the blood of the slain be avenged by justice is not an opinion: it is the fifth commandment itself. When a tribunal condemns the murderer of the poor and the weak, it fulfils the office that tradition recognises in the magistrate. The law that protects the schoolgirl against the violent man, and the unarmed native against the one who covets his land, is the same law, for it covers every man without distinction of condition. On this point, the appeal heard in the Amazon meets the perennial doctrine.
One reservation remains, and it is not a matter of form. In the perpetual teaching, the gravity of murder lies not in the forest but in man: the murdered defender cries out to heaven because he is made in the image of God, not because a tree has fallen. "The cry of the earth" has weight only insofar as it is first the cry of the poor. Whoever would set creation before the creature would overturn the very order that the commandment protects.
For the faithful
The precept that forbids killing also commands charity toward one's neighbour: to feed the hungry, to protect the weak, to lend no hand to crime, neither "by one's counsels, by one's means, by one's help." The Christian holds that the blood of the innocent calls for justice here below and judgment on high, and that no man, however destitute, is outside the law of God.
Sources. Catechism of the Council of Trent (1566), on the fifth commandment. Genesis 4:10, according to the Vulgate.