The Spiritual Life
What Does God Say About Judging Others?
What does God say about judging others? Christ forbids rash judgment of hearts and hypocrisy — not the judgment of acts as right or wrong, which charity requires.

What does God say about judging others? In St Matthew (Matt vii. 1) Our Lord says: "Judge not, that you may not be judged." This forbids the rash judgment of hearts and motives and the hypocrisy of the man who condemns in others the sin he excuses in himself. It does not forbid the judgment of acts as right or wrong — which charity itself requires. We may and must judge deeds; we may not judge the secret state of a soul.
Matthew 7:1 — what "judge not" in the Bible actually forbids
The "judge not" passage in the Bible must be read together, not torn from its place. Our Lord goes on: "For with what judgment you judge, you shall be judged... And why seest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye; and seest not the beam that is in thy own eye?" (Matt vii. 2-3). The man condemned here is the one who scrutinises his neighbour's small fault while nursing a great one of his own — the censorious spirit that sets itself up as a tribunal over other men's souls. Christ does not say there is no mote and no beam. He says: deal with thine own first.
So Matthew 7:1 is not an abolition of all moral judgment. It is a command against one sin: usurping the place of God, who alone reads hearts. "Judge not" forbids us to pronounce on what we cannot see — the interior guilt, the secret intention, the final standing of a soul before God. Of these only God is judge, "for man seeth those things that appear, but the Lord beholdeth the heart" (1 Kings xvi. 7).
The modern misreading: "never call anything sin"
A popular reading turns "judge not" into a rule that no one may ever call any act sinful, that to name a wrong is itself the one forbidden judgment. This is a corruption of the text, and it cannot stand against Scripture. The same Lord who said "Judge not" also said "Judge not according to the appearance, but judge just judgment" (John vii. 24) — a direct command to judge, and to judge rightly.
He told His disciples, "If thy brother shall offend against thee, go, and rebuke him between thee and him alone" (Matt xviii. 15) — which is impossible unless one has first judged that an offence was committed. St Paul rebukes the Corinthians precisely for failing to judge a public sin in their midst: "Do not you judge them that are within?" (1 Cor v. 12).
The distinction is exact. To say "this act is theft, this is adultery, this is blasphemy" is to judge the deed by the law of God, and this every Christian is bound to do; without it there is no conscience, no correction, no examination of conscience at all. To say "this man is damned, his heart is malice, God has rejected him" is to judge the soul, and this is forbidden, because we do not see the heart. The first is the work of charity and truth; the second is the sin Our Lord condemns. Confusing them is how the modern misreading empties the Gospel of its moral force. For what the moral law binds us to discern, see the Ten Commandments, the seven deadly sins, and mortal and venial sin.
Rash judgment: the sin against the Eighth Commandment
The Church has always named the forbidden judgment precisely: it is rash judgment, a sin against the Eighth Commandment, "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour." The Catechism of St Pius X teaches that this commandment "forbids us defamation or detraction, calumny, flattery, rash judgment and suspicion, and every kind of lie," and defines it: "Rash judgment or suspicion is a sin which consists in judging ill of, or suspecting evil of, one's neighbour without a just motive."
The malice of rash judgment lies in that phrase — without a just motive. To hold a man guilty on no evidence, to read the worst into an act that bears an innocent reading, to fix in the mind a verdict the facts do not warrant: this is to bear false witness against him in the secret court of one's own thoughts. The Catechism of the Council of Trent, on the same commandment, condemns the man "secretly tearing and outraging one's neighbour," and reaches even the one who listens to detraction with pleasure, "for there would be no detractor if there were no one to listen to detraction."
St Thomas treats this directly. Judgment is an act of justice; it is lawful and good when made by lawful authority, from a right motive, and according to the truth (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 60, a. 2). It becomes unlawful — rash — when a man judges his neighbour's hidden faults on slight or no grounds; and in doubt St Thomas lays down the rule of charity: we must interpret a doubtful thing in the better sense, for it is better to err by thinking well of a bad man than by thinking ill of a good one (II-II, q. 60, a. 3-4). The Catechism of St Pius X says the same as a positive command: the Eighth Commandment binds us "to interpret in a good sense, as far as we can, the actions of our neighbour."
What we may judge, and what we may not
The line is now clear, and it is firm on both sides.
We may and must judge acts. We must know good from evil and call each by its name; this is the use of conscience and the ground of all repentance. The law of God is a measure laid against deeds, and to apply it is not pride but obedience. A father judges his child's lie a lie; a confessor judges a penitent's act a sin to be absolved; the Church judges heresy heresy. To refuse this is not humility — it is the false charity that watches a man walk to the edge and says nothing. The fraternal correction Our Lord commands (Matt xviii. 15) rests on it, and so does the duty of confession, where the sinner judges his own acts and brings them to be forgiven, according to the power of the keys.
We may not judge the soul. We cannot see whether a man sinned with full knowledge and full consent, whether he has since repented in secret, whether grace has already met him where we cannot follow. To pronounce on his final standing is to seize a throne that belongs to God alone, who "will render to every man according to his works." This is why the saints, who saw sin most clearly, judged souls least: they hated the fault and pitied the man.
This governs every hard case where men put contempt in the place of charity. We may judge that an act is gravely disordered — as the tradition does plainly with homosexuality, sex before marriage, and the sins of the flesh marked on the body in tattoos and piercings — without consigning the man who commits it to perdition. The charity that forbids us to flatter sin forbids us to despair of the sinner. On the stakes hidden in every soul's secret, see the four last things and does hell exist; for the virtue that must clothe all our dealings, see what does God say about love and love is patient, love is kind.
The beam in thine own eye
Our Lord ends the passage where every honest reader must end: "Thou hypocrite, cast out first the beam out of thy own eye, and then shalt thou see to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye" (Matt vii. 5). He does not forbid the casting out of the mote — He orders it, afterward. The rash judge is condemned not because he sees his brother's fault, but because he sees it while blind to his own.
The remedy is not to stop judging acts; it is to judge oneself first, severely, and one's neighbour last, and gently — which is how to love God worked out toward our neighbour. And it is the safe path: "with what judgment you judge, you shall be judged." The soul that thinks well of others where it honestly can, corrects where it must, and leaves the heart to God, finds in the end the mercy it gave.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does God say about forgiving others?
We are bound to forgive without measure: "If you will forgive men their offences, your heavenly Father will forgive you also your offences. But if you will not forgive men, neither will your Father forgive you your offences" (Matt vi. 14-15). When St Peter asked whether seven times was enough, Our Lord answered, "I say not to thee, till seven times; but till seventy times seven times" (Matt xviii. 22). To forgive is not to call the wrong no wrong, but to surrender all rancour and desire of revenge, leaving justice to God. See what does God say about forgiveness.
What did Jesus say about forgiving others?
Our Lord made our own forgiveness depend on it. In the Our Father He taught us to pray, "Forgive us our debts, as we also forgive our debtors" (Matt vi. 12), and added at once that the Father will not forgive the man who refuses to forgive his brother (Matt vi. 14-15). When Peter asked how often, Christ answered "till seventy times seven times" (Matt xviii. 22) and told the parable of the unmerciful servant, who was handed to the torturers for exacting a small debt after his own great one was remitted. From the Cross He showed it perfectly: "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do" (Luke xxiii. 34).
What does God say about judging?
He forbids one kind of judgment and commands another. "Judge not, that you may not be judged" (Matt vii. 1) condemns rash judgment of hearts and the hypocrisy that condemns in others what it excuses in itself; but the same Lord says, "Judge not according to the appearance, but judge just judgment" (John vii. 24). We may and must judge acts by the law of God; we may never pronounce on the secret state of a soul, "for man seeth those things that appear, but the Lord beholdeth the heart" (1 Kings xvi. 7).
What does God say about loving others?
This is the second great commandment: "Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself" (Matt xxii. 39). Our Lord makes it the mark of His disciples — "By this shall all men know that you are my disciples, if you have love one for another" (John xiii. 35) — and extends it even to enemies: "Love your enemies: do good to them that hate you" (Matt v. 44). This charity is not soft flattery of sin but the willing of true good to another, which is why it both corrects the fault and pities the man. See what does God say about love.
What does God say about helping others?
Charity toward our neighbour is no mere feeling but the works of mercy. Our Lord identifies Himself with the needy — "as long as you did it to one of these my least brethren, you did it to me" (Matt xxv. 40) — and the parable of the Good Samaritan answers "Who is my neighbour?" by showing mercy in deed to the stranger fallen by the road (Luke x. 30-37). St James warns that faith without such works is dead: "if a brother or sister be naked, and want daily food... what shall it profit?" (James ii. 15-17). To help our neighbour in his need is the love of God made visible.
What does God say about praying for others?
St Paul commands it plainly: "I desire therefore, first of all, that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all men" (1 Tim ii. 1). Our Lord bids us pray even for those who wrong us: "Pray for them that persecute and calumniate you" (Matt v. 44). To pray for another is the highest charity we can show, for it asks God to give him what we cannot — and it guards our own hearts from the rancour that breeds rash judgment.
What does God say about giving to others?
Almsgiving is a duty and a treasure laid up in heaven. "Give, and it shall be given to you: good measure and pressed down and shaken together and running over shall they give into your bosom" (Luke vi. 38). Our Lord praised the widow who gave two mites because "she of her want cast in all she had" (Mark xii. 44), and bade us give in secret, "that thy alms may be in secret, and thy Father who seeth in secret will repay thee" (Matt vi. 4). To give to the poor is to lend to the Lord, who will not be outdone in generosity.
What does God say about trusting others?
Scripture counsels both charity and prudence. Charity "thinketh no evil" and "believeth all things" (1 Cor xiii. 5-7), inclining us to interpret a neighbour's doubtful act in the better sense, as the Eighth Commandment requires. Yet our final trust belongs to God alone: "It is good to confide in the Lord, rather than to have confidence in man" (Ps cxvii. 8). We owe men good will and the benefit of the doubt; we owe God our whole reliance.
What does God say about treating others?
The rule Our Lord gives is the Golden Rule: "All things therefore whatsoever you would that men should do to you, do you also to them. For this is the law and the prophets" (Matt vii. 12). To treat others rightly is to deal with them as we would be dealt with — judging their acts justly, thinking well of them where we honestly can, correcting in charity and never in contempt, and leaving their souls to the God who alone reads hearts.
So the answer holds, neither softened nor inflated. God forbids us to judge the secret state of a soul, to think evil of our neighbour without a just motive, to play the hypocrite who condemns in others what he keeps in himself. He does not forbid us to judge deeds by His law — He commands it, and charity requires it. Judge not the heart; judge rightly the act; cast the beam from thine own eye first. For more plain answers from the tradition, see the hub what does God say about and the Catholic Bible verses collection.
The Iter Fidei app carries the Douay-Rheims Bible, the catechism, the prayers and devotions. Get the app link by email here.
Sources. Scripture per the Douay-Rheims: St Matthew vii. 1-5; St John vii. 24; St Matthew xviii. 15; 1 Corinthians v. 12; 1 Kings (1 Samuel) xvi. 7. Catechism of St Pius X (1908), Third Part, "The Eighth Commandment" (rash judgment, suspicion, detraction, calumny; the duty to interpret a neighbour's actions in a good sense). Catechism of the Council of Trent (Roman Catechism, 1566), Chapter on the Eighth Commandment (false witness, detraction and calumny, the duty to judge with equity). St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 60, "On Judgment," a. 2 (the conditions of lawful judgment), a. 3-4 (rash judgment and the rule of interpreting doubtful things in the better sense).